This easy homemade Nutter Butter ice cream is a no brainer for people who love peanut butter. Making sweetened condensed ice cream recipes is one of my favorite weekend activities and this one is amazing! If you have never used store bought cookies in a homemade ice cream recipe you have been missing out. If you want a peanut buttery taste then Nutter Butter cookies are the way to go. They are easy to crumble up in the ice cream and they bring the peanut butter flavor I am looking for.